According to the investigation, A.F.A., O.P.A., and H.N.A., having previously agreed, together with J.S. and unidentified individuals, forged decision No. 289 of the Shark ayil okmotu, dated April 2, 2007, regarding the allocation of a land plot of 0.5 hectares into private ownership.
This forged decision was submitted along with an application on December 17, 2021, to the Kara-Suu branch of "Cadastre" for registration. The application was handed over to A.F.A. for execution. Together with N.H., he went to the site on December 15, 2021, and drew up a land allocation act without waiting for official registration.
Based on this act, N.H. prepared a coordinating document, which was presented to the ayil okmotu for the signature of the responsible secretary. These forged documents were then submitted to the Kara-Suu branch of "Cadastre" for registration.
The investigation established that on December 31, 2021, P.O., knowing that J.S. already had a previously allocated plot, grossly violated the rules for granting land plots and registered the act in the name of J.S., even though he had not submitted an application or attended a land commission meeting.
A.F., realizing the illegality of the land allocation act, retrieved from the archive the registration file related to the state act in the name of J.S. and made changes to it. During the investigation, it was discovered that he changed the date of the act from the 15th to a later date.
According to the conclusion of the Osh Regional State Archive, there are no documents in the archive confirming the allocation of a land plot to J.S. by decision No. 289 dated April 2, 2007. The market value of this plot is 687,500 soms, according to the conclusion of the forensic expert center "Business Aspect" dated April 12, 2023.
The examination also confirmed that the signatures and seal on the forged decision No. 289 are fake, and that N.H. indeed signed the coordinating documents.
Investigative actions showed that J.S., working in the tax service, was aware of the existing laws and that he had already been allocated a plot. Nevertheless, he submitted an application with a forged decision, which violates the law.
As a result, J.S. received a state act for a land plot of 500 square meters, which was actually intended for another applicant.
By the verdict of the Kara-Suu District Court dated August 7, 2024, A.F.A. was acquitted on many counts of the Criminal Code due to lack of evidence of a crime. Similar decisions were made regarding other participants in the case: S.Z.B., O.P.A., and H.N.A., who were also acquitted.
The Judicial Board of the Osh Regional Court on January 24, 2025, annulled some parts of the verdict, finding A.F.A., O.P.A., and H.N.A. guilty of negligence. S.Z.B. was found guilty of document forgery and sentenced to a fine of 50,000 soms.
The Supreme Court upheld the decision of the Osh Regional Court, leaving it in force.
